HAMILTON INSURANCE GROUP - Key Persons


Amber Nicoletti

Job Titles:
  • Account Manager Last Names a - G

Audrey McCartney

Job Titles:
  • Account Manager

Brian Hamilton - VP of Sales

Job Titles:
  • Vice President of Sales
Brian Hamilton, Neil's son, graduated from Mansfield Saint Peter's High School. Brian then attended Ohio State University and Toledo University before joining the agency. Brian worked throughout his high school and college career at Westbrook Country Club. Brian joined the agency in 2009 and is licensed to write all forms of Property and Casualty Insurance. In 2014, Brian became Senior Vice President of Sales. His focus is on auto, home and commercial lines of business. He is an active member in the Spherion 13er committee, Part of the 2015-2016 Leadership Unlimited Class and serves on the Richland Academy of the Arts Board. Brian married Abby in 2010 and together they have a son and a daughter.

Chris Starkey

Job Titles:
  • Account Manager Last Names H - O
Chris Starkey graduated from Lexington High School and attended Ashland University. After college he did some traveling and spent time managing a hotel in Alaska and then worked at Desert Mountain Country Club in Arizona. He returned to Ohio to work at Scioto Country Club in Columbus. In November 2014, Chris became licensed in Property and Casualty Insurance. He is account manager for our personal lines insurance clients and services auto and home insurance policies. He married Jamie Henry in 2013 and together they have two children.

Christine Myers - CFO

Job Titles:
  • Chief Financial Officer
Christine Myers graduated from Mansfield St. Peters and pursued a degree in Elementary Education from Bowling Green State University. After teaching for 6 years, Christine took a break from teaching and pursued a Master's Degree in School Administration from the University of Cincinnati, graduating in 2010. During this time she started working part time doing clerical work for the Agency. Although she has been working in the family business since 2007, Christine became a licensed insurance agent through the State of Ohio in 2012. She has been providing service for our customer's auto and home insurance as a customer service representative since 2012. In 2013, Christine was promoted to office manager. In 2014, Christine was promoted to Vice President. She currently holds the position of Chief Financial Officer. Christine married Steven Myers of Mansfield in 2007. Together they have four children.

David Sipes

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Ed Gutchall

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Emily Nalley

Job Titles:
  • Admin Assistant

John Kennedy

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Lori Holden Sjostedt

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Mary Jo Wagner

Job Titles:
  • Commercial Account Manager

Michael Hamilton

Job Titles:
  • Vice President of Commercial Lines
Michael Hamilton, Neil's youngest son, graduated from Ontario High School before attending Ohio State University. He has completed the Insurance program through the Fisher College of Business at Ohio State University and is scheduled to graduate in December 2015. While at Ohio State, Michael served as treasurer of Alpha Sigma Phi and currently serves on the House Corporation Board. Michael is working currently on ARM, Associate in Risk Management and on earning his CPCU, which stands for Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriter. Michael is a licensed agent in Property, Casualty, Life and Health Insurance. Michael specializes on Commercial and Business insurance.

Neil Hamilton - CEO, President

Job Titles:
  • CEO
  • President

Neil Shideler

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Nicole Williamson

Job Titles:
  • Commercial Account Manager

Rob Pittman

Job Titles:
  • Employee Benefits Sales Rep
  • Sales

Ronda Stone

Job Titles:
  • Senior Account Manager - Commercial Lines
  • Senior Accounts Manager
Ronda Stone began her career in insurance in 1998. After 15 years of servicing accounts in the Coshocton, Ohio area, Ronda moved back to Mansfield and joined Hamilton Insurance Group, Inc. Ronda is the Senior Accounts Manager and works closely with commercial lines policies. Although she specializes in Commercial Lines, Ronda is licensed and able to service all of our auto, home and commercial lines policies. She is also a notary. Ronda currently resides in Mansfield with her husband Gary. They have two children and five grandchildren, which keeps them very busy attending school activities and sporting events. Gary and Ronda are members of Little Washington Congregational Church.

Sarah Ludwig

Job Titles:
  • Agent

Tammy Smallstey

Job Titles:
  • Senior Account Manager Last Names P - Z